Why This Innovation Agency Stopped Pitching and Hires for Behaviour Over Skills: Jenny from Magnetic on the Happy Teams Podcast

The Innovation Agency That Stopped Pitching

Jenny from Magnetic walked away from pitching. Not because she couldn't win, but because the process had become a procurement exercise that rarely suited the work Magnetic does.

"We sell solutions, but we don't always know what the solution's going to be," Jenny explains. "Sometimes we don't even know what the problem is." A client arrives with a brief and Magnetic tells them the problem is somewhere else entirely. That doesn't lend itself to a competitive pitch process with a fixed scope.

Instead, Magnetic operates on relationships. It takes longer to start a project, but once it begins, the foundation is already in place. "Innovation takes people out of their comfort zone," Jenny says. "If the relationship isn't there when you start, it's hard."

Internally, Magnetic runs a programme called Jumpstart, hiring six to eight people a year into entry-level innovation and design roles. They recruit career changers, returning parents, and graduates, screening for curiosity, generosity, and a willingness to act. High egos get removed from the process. "If they don't have the right behaviours and mindset, they're not going to work in our culture," Jenny says.

Their annual book, now in its ninth edition, reaches 8,000 readers. Clients collect them and ask to be featured. During the pandemic, when the team debated whether to produce one at all, Jenny pushed ahead. She dialled into a call with a senior client and spotted every previous edition lined up on his bookshelf in the background.

"I went straight back to the team and said, guys, we have to do the book."

Listen to the full conversation with Jenny on the Happy Teams podcast.

"Such an easy time finding and hiring qualified candidates. I wish hiring in the US was this easy!"

Profile picture.

Noelle TasseyFounder & CEO, coLab

"Our Webflow developer has been absolutely astounding. I highly recommend Prodigi’s service."

Profile picture.

Hannah SpringettCEO & Founder, HLabs

"Prodigi understands agencies really well. Everything has been positive. I’d definitely recommend Prodigi."

Profile picture.

Paul GoodingsOperations Manager, Hedgehog Lab

"Prodigi found me top calibre talent. I certainly would recommend Prodigi."

Profile picture.

Will BagnallCEO, SUSO

"We had talent working within a week. Prodigi far exceeded any of the usual resourcers that we work with."

Profile picture.

Sammy MansourpourMD, Agency UK

"Prodigi really worked with us to make sure that they understood the need that we had and matched us with the right talent."

Profile picture.

Darrell NoeFounder & CEO, Seventy Seven Collective

"The process went smoothly, the candidates were great and it all worked out tremendously."

Profile picture.

Micah DonahueSVP Media, Carbon

1/4